Quote:
|
Originally Posted by ahopper
Is the 150' rule necessary??
I grew up boating on Winnipesaukee and recently had an experience boating in Florida where they don't have a 150' rule. Boat traffic seems to flow just fine down there?
I think it's possible for boats to safely pass within 50' of each other.
What do you think? Does anyone know the origins of the 150' rule?
|
I would agree that there are times when you can safely pass another boat at distances < 150', but there are times when that isn't true as well. The small boat / large boat scenario is one. Another is when the passing boats are not running parallel (or anti-) courses. If someone estimates the intercept a bit off you may not have enough space & time to manuver out of it.
It's the nature of rules to be limiting even in those circumstances when they're not needed, so they will be followed (and be enforcable) when they are needed. That's why "we" should be careful in what we request of our rule makers, and try to actually consider all the viewpoints and make an informed decision of what to ask for. You know the old saying ....
