The island gets the joker's mezza-mezza rating.
One of my lake neighbors (a man with questionable tastes in ohh so many ways), loves the island. But this is a man who brings his own italian salad dressing everywhere.
If you're looking for quality atmosphere and a melt in your mouth prime rib, look elsewhere. If you're out for a fun night, a decent meal, more than a few beverages, and have mad maggie's cab to get you home, this is the place.