Across from the Walmart plaza is "Cookin' at the Lakeside", which used to be over on the boulevard at what is called, I think, Paugus Plaza. Never noticed if they offer beer and wine, we normally eat lunch there, but have had supper there. Family fare in the manner of the Tilt'n Diner.
Sawyer's...we had a nice lunch there recently, other's haven't been so happy with it.
Ellacoya Barn and Grille on Rte 11 just east of Ellacoya State park and Lake shore park. We have had lunch and dinner there, and it is one of our favs. On weekends, reservations may be in order.
Where the old William Tell was in West Alton on rte 11, it is now the Woodlands Tavern. We have had dinner there, and liked it. Suggest reservations on the weekend.
In Lakeport, you have Fratello's, O's, Cactus Jacks, and TBones.
Hope you have season's passes to Meadowbrook...there a lot of choices to try here!!!!!
