Winnipesaukee Forum

Winnipesaukee Forum (https://www.winnipesaukee.com/forums/index.php)
-   Restaurant Information & Reviews (https://www.winnipesaukee.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   Affordable Lobster Roll (https://www.winnipesaukee.com/forums/showthread.php?t=30642)

retired 07-23-2026 08:46 PM

Affordable Lobster Roll
 
With friends visiting next week, we are looking to treat them to our local delicacy. But the restaurants we have seen are all ridiculously expensive. Pops in Alton is over $40 and everyone else is over $30. Is there any reasonably priced lobster roll left in the Lakes Region?

DesertDweller 07-23-2026 09:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retired (Post 408636)
With friends visiting next week, we are looking to treat them to our local delicacy. But the restaurants we have seen are all ridiculously expensive. Pops in Alton is over $40 and everyone else is over $30. Is there any reasonably priced lobster roll left in the Lakes Region?

$30+ seems to be the going rate. What about making them yourself? Not exactly a complex recipe and you could season them to your liking.

TiltonBB 07-23-2026 09:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retired (Post 408636)
With friends visiting next week, we are looking to treat them to our local delicacy. But the restaurants we have seen are all ridiculously expensive. Pops in Alton is over $40 and everyone else is over $30. Is there any reasonably priced lobster roll left in the Lakes Region?

Are you sure about Pop's price? My recollection is a lobster roll with fries is $29.95.

Winilyme 07-23-2026 09:52 PM

What’s taking FLL so long to weigh in?

jbolty 07-24-2026 05:40 AM

$36 at poor peoples pub and the top rated by wmur

Biggd 07-24-2026 08:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Winilyme (Post 408640)
What’s taking FLL so long to weigh in?

I'm sure Market Basket or McDonalds is the only place he shops for food!

BroadHopper 07-24-2026 08:13 AM

Visa Foods
 
In Laconia is where the locals go! They prepare them to your order. Naked, mayo, butter, with lettuce etc. 29.95, huge and so worth it!

TomC 07-24-2026 08:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Biggd (Post 408643)
I'm sure Market Basket or McDonalds is the only place he shops for food!

Nah - he flips over some rocks, grabs some crayfish, and makes his own Free Lake Lobster roll :laugh:

SAMIAM 07-24-2026 10:13 AM

Red Hill Dari in Center Harbor charges $29.95 for a full 1/4 lb lobster roll….cold only with mayo. Delicious. Micki makes the best onion rings on the planet….get a roll and an order of rings. You wont be disappointed

TiltonBB 07-24-2026 10:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SAMIAM (Post 408649)
Red Hill Dari in Center Harbor charges $29.95 for a full 1/4 lb lobster roll….cold only with mayo. Delicious. Micki makes the best onion rings on the planet….get a roll and an order of rings. You wont be disappointed

We went by boat to Center Harbor last week for lobster rolls at Red Hill Dari. Great as usual.

retired 07-24-2026 11:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TiltonBB (Post 408638)
Are you sure about Pop's price? My recollection is a lobster roll with fries is $29.95.

My cousin told me that. Could be fake news.

ghfromaltonbay 07-24-2026 11:25 AM

Pops Clam Shack
 
The price on the menu board for the lobster roll is $29.95 today. Their menu can be viewed online. There is a combo plate for $44.95 which includes fried clams, lobster roll & fries.

retired 07-25-2026 10:45 AM

Looks like $29.95 is the price this summer. Not too high.
I remember when Vista sold them for $14.99 about 8 years ago.

Mr. V 07-25-2026 11:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retired (Post 408669)
Looks like $29.95 is the price this summer. Not too high.
I remember when Vista sold them for $14.99 about 8 years ago.

I'm sorry, but thirty bucks for a sandwich is high.

Yeah, lobster is expensive but the price is still high for what is only a sandwich.

FlyingScot 07-25-2026 03:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SAMIAM (Post 408649)
Red Hill Dari in Center Harbor charges $29.95 for a full 1/4 lb lobster roll….cold only with mayo. Delicious. Micki makes the best onion rings on the planet….get a roll and an order of rings. You wont be disappointed

I had the Red Hill lobster roll a few days ago--very good.

Also, OP--as you note--lobster roll is a "delicacy", you do not want a cheap one. It will just cause your guests to shake their heads and wonder why you made a big deal about them.

One other place not too far from Belmont--Johnson's in New Durham. Excellent lobster rolls and also a great whole lobster dinner. I do not remember their prices, but they are generally low compared to places on the lake

barefootbay 07-25-2026 08:42 PM

No such thing anymore . Just the lowest of the over inflated prices!

Major 07-27-2026 02:32 PM

Market Basket
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Biggd (Post 408643)
I'm sure Market Basket or McDonalds is the only place he shops for food!

My dad swears by the lobster roll finger sandwiches prepared by Market Basket. Affordable and very good!

Descant 07-27-2026 04:36 PM

Diy
 
To me, lobster salad is labor intensive, so expensive. The "real lobster experience" is taking the lobster apart yourself. I see lobster dinners same price or cheaper than the lobster roll. Even less $$ if you buy lobster and cook it yourself. Add corn, steamers and "Lady of the Lake" beer from Abel Ebenezer Brewery in Merrimack, but widely distributed in NH (It's a crisp New England Lager).

BroadHopper 07-31-2026 12:41 PM

Visa Foods
 
Until supplies run out. Lobster Rolls available for $22.95

SAB1 07-31-2026 02:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr. V (Post 408671)
I'm sorry, but thirty bucks for a sandwich is high.

Yeah, lobster is expensive but the price is still high for what is only a sandwich.

Agree. They are overpriced and honestly not that great anyway. Much better seafood options at better prices.

TiltonBB 07-31-2026 02:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BroadHopper (Post 408796)
Until supplies run out. Lobster Rolls available for $22.95

Are you going to share the location or is this your secret?

BroadHopper 07-31-2026 03:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TiltonBB (Post 408799)
Are you going to share the location or is this your secret?

VISA FOODS S Main St, Laconia


Sent from my SM-S721U using Tapatalk

thinkxingu 07-31-2026 03:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TiltonBB (Post 408799)
Are you going to share the location or is this your secret?

Visa Foods is what it says in the subject line, but not everybody can see that (I can't—had to use web view).

Sent from my SM-S931U using Tapatalk

fatlazyless 07-31-2026 03:47 PM

"Lobster is a shellfish crustacean that scavenges and feeds on the ocean floor, including dead animals, fish, and organic matter. They are bottom-dwellers with hard outer shells and jointed legs.

Food: Mostly eats fresh or decaying fish, clams, crabs, sea urchins, and worms on the seabed."

From Google AI overview

Major 07-31-2026 04:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thinkxingu (Post 408805)
Visa Foods is what it says in the subject line, but not everybody can see that (I can't—had to use web view).

Sent from my SM-S931U using Tapatalk

I think it's actually called Vista Foods. South Main Street, Laconia.

Descant 07-31-2026 04:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BroadHopper (Post 408796)
Until supplies run out. Lobster Rolls available for $22.95

Is that 4 oz or 5 oz?

BroadHopper 07-31-2026 04:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Descant (Post 408810)
Is that 4 oz or 5 oz?

They don't say but looks pretty big to me! They make them to order, hot, cold, buttered, mayo, or plain. Any fixing you want! I like mine on a bed of lettuce.

Sent from my SM-S721U using Tapatalk

BroadHopper 07-31-2026 04:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Descant (Post 408810)
Is that 4 oz or 5 oz?

Heading down now! And enjoy it with a great blues band on Canal St. Starts at 5:30. Michael Vincent Band. See you there!

Sent from my SM-S721U using Tapatalk

pondguy 07-31-2026 07:13 PM

Hannaford
 
Just looked at the Hannaford flyer for next week starting sunday 6 oz $9.99 :liplick:

retired 07-31-2026 08:47 PM

Yeah, we got sucked in by the price too. I don't think it's really lobster. Either way it sucked.

pondguy 08-01-2026 05:10 AM

Made in store with North Atlantic Lobster on a brioche roll.

BillTex 08-01-2026 08:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pondguy (Post 408820)
Made in store with North Atlantic Lobster on a brioche roll.

Very likely (frozen) Canadian. Typical for “big box” locations.

pondguy 08-02-2026 07:16 AM

Well I guess I learned something new today Hannafords lies in their sale flyers. Thanks for the tip! :confused:

FlyingScot 08-02-2026 09:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pondguy (Post 408832)
Well I guess I learned something new today Hannafords lies in their sale flyers. Thanks for the tip! :confused:

I don't see how you learned that, especially with the frozen Canadian explanation. I also don't see how anyone could believe that $6.99 will yield a good lobster roll

pondguy 08-02-2026 01:08 PM

Just had one for lunch it was quite good. $9.99

pjard 08-02-2026 01:27 PM

From where?

Quote:

Originally Posted by pondguy (Post 408835)
Just had one for lunch it was quite good. $9.99


retired 08-28-2026 11:02 AM

I think I found the cheapest lobster rolls around.
Market Basket has lobster on sale for $7.99 this week.
We bought three small ones, cooked and packaged, brought them home, took the meat out and made lobster salad. Total cost for four lobster rolls was about $18.00. $4.50 apiece and they were absolutely delicious.

BroadHopper 10-12-2026 01:23 PM

Visa Foods
 
Just brought home two lobster rolls from this market! $16.99 each!


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 02:45 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.